Advocating for Top-Two Open Primaries: A Move Towards Fair Representation in Utah

Advocating for Top-Two Open Primaries: A Move Towards Fair Representation in Utah


In Utah, the political framework is heavily influenced by the role of delegates and the caucus/convention system. Although designed to encourage grassroots participation, this approach has ignited discussions regarding representation and the equity of the nominating process. To tackle these issues and foster a more democratic method, People4Utah supports the adoption of top-two open primaries.

Examining the Current System: Issues and Constraints

Utah utilizes a caucus-convention system instead of traditional primaries. Party members convene in local caucuses to elect delegates who then participate in party conventions. These delegates cast votes to nominate candidates for various offices, including primary elections. However, with caucus participation at less than 10% this year, the chosen delegates may not adequately represent the wider range of Utah voices. This gap raises questions about whether the nominees truly embody the diverse viewpoints within the Republican party.

The Impact of SB 54

The passage of Senate Bill 54 (SB54) in 2014 introduced a dual pathway for candidates to secure a spot on the primary ballot. While SB 54 diluted the influence of delegates by allowing candidates to gather signatures, the high thresholds for signature collection often favor those with financial resources. Consequently, the signature pathway remains elusive for many aspiring candidates, perpetuating the dominance of the delegate-driven nomination process.

The Case for Top-Two Open Primaries

To create a more inclusive and democratic process, People4Utah proposes transitioning to a top-two open primary system. Here are the key benefits of this system:

1. Increased Voter Participation

A top-two open primary system allows all candidates, regardless of party affiliation, to compete in a single primary open to all voters. By allowing all registered voters to participate in the primary, this system ensures a broader representation of the electorate’s preferences. This inclusivity leads to higher voter turnout and engagement, reflecting the true will of the people.

3. Enhanced Competition

The top-two system encourages healthy competition among candidates. By focusing on the general electorate rather than a small group of party loyalists, candidates are motivated to present comprehensive and appealing platforms. This leads to more robust policy discussions and better-qualified candidates who are prepared to address the needs and concerns of all constituents.

4. Empowerment of Unaffiliated Voters

In the current system, unaffiliated voters often feel disenfranchised. The top-two open primary allows them to have a meaningful voice in the selection of candidates, ensuring their perspectives are included in the political discourse. This empowerment of unaffiliated voters strengthens the democratic process and enhances civic engagement.

5. Reduction in Partisan Gridlock

By encouraging candidates to appeal to a broader electorate, the top-two open primary system can reduce partisan gridlock. Candidates who are elected through this system are more likely to seek common ground and work collaboratively across party lines, leading to more effective governance and the implementation of policies that benefit the entire community.

6. Greater Accountability

Candidates in a top-two open primary system must be accountable to a wider range of voters. This fosters a more inclusive and representative political process, as elected officials are more likely to consider the diverse perspectives of their entire electorate rather than catering to a narrow base. This accountability ensures that elected officials work for the benefit of all citizens, promoting policies that reflect the collective interests of the community.

Moving Forward

Utah finds itself at a pivotal juncture in its electoral journey. By embracing the top-two open primary system, we can lay the groundwork for a more equitable and representative political landscape. The pursuit of fairness and democracy remains central to shaping the destiny of Utah and its people. Let’s respond to the call for reform and embark on a collective journey towards a more inclusive and representative political future.

For more information on how you can support electoral reform in Utah, visit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *